首页 > AI前沿 > From Arraignment to Resolution: Transformer Models of Court Cases

From Arraignment to Resolution: Transformer Models of Court Cases

arXiv自然语言 2026-11-19 13:00 3 阅读 查看原文
用户要求将提供的纯文本新闻正文排版成语义化的HTML片段。 规则如下: 1. 只输出HTML片段本身,不要Markdown围栏、不要解释。 2. 每个自然段落用`

`包裹,长文用`

`/`

`划分小节。 3. 列表内容用`
  • `,引用用`
    `,代码用`
    `,重要句子可用``。
    4. 保留原文所有信息,不得增删改内容。
    5. 不要输出``/``/``等文档级标签。
    
    提供的正文:
    The criminal legal system is composed of many complex decision points, such as which charges are pursued, how bond is determined, plea deal negotiations, and sentencing. Given the profound impact of such decisions, there is a growing need to increase the transparency within this system. While prior machine learning approaches have focused on modeling single decisions (e.g., recidivism), this paper proposes a transformer-based time series model to forecast the outcome of the next proceeding in a case (e.g., charges accepted, bond set, plea deal made, etc.). By modeling a case as an event sequence, we enable a more nuanced analysis to support better oversight and understanding of decision making. We conduct an empirical analysis of thousands of cases using a newly constructed dataset derived from publicly available court records of a mid-sized U.S. city. We fit models that combine textual data from clerk notes with structured information about the defendant, prior charges, and courtroom. Our transformer model achieves $.57$ micro-F1 on a 20-class multi-label task, a significant improvement over several baselines and comparable to a GRU trained on the same input. We demonstrate how the model can be used to provide insights into decision-making and help court observers identify emerging issues within the jurisdiction studied.
    
    分析正文结构:
    这是一段学术/科技新闻摘要,没有明显的小节标题需求,但为了符合“长文用

    /

    划分小节”的提示(虽然这里不长,可以加一个

    作为文章标题或者直接分段)。 不过用户给的是“正文如下”,没有标题。如果加标题算“增删改内容”吗?最好不加标题,或者把第一句作为段落。 或者可以划分几个逻辑段落: 段落1:背景与问题。 "The criminal legal system is composed of many complex decision points, such as which charges are pursued, how bond is determined, plea deal negotiations, and sentencing. Given the profound impact of such decisions, there is a growing need to increase the transparency within this system." 段落2:方法与创新。 "While prior machine learning approaches have focused on modeling single decisions (e.g., recidivism), this paper proposes a transformer-based time series model to forecast the outcome of the next proceeding in a case (e.g., charges accepted, bond set, plea deal made, etc.). By modeling a case as an event sequence, we enable a more nuanced analysis to support better oversight and understanding of decision making." 段落3:实验与结果。 "We conduct an empirical analysis of thousands of cases using a newly constructed dataset derived from publicly available court records of a mid-sized U.S. city. We fit models that combine textual data from clerk notes with structured information about the defendant, prior charges, and courtroom. Our transformer model achieves $.57$ micro-F1 on a 20-class multi-label task, a significant improvement over several baselines and comparable to a GRU trained on the same input." 段落4:应用与意义。 "We demonstrate how the model can be used to provide insights into decision-making and help court observers identify emerging issues within the jurisdiction studied." 检查重要句子,可以用``。比如包含关键模型和结果的句子。 "this paper proposes a transformer-based time series model to forecast the outcome of the next proceeding in a case" "Our transformer model achieves $.57$ micro-F1 on a 20-class multi-label task, a significant improvement over several baselines and comparable to a GRU trained on the same input." 不要增删改内容,所以只加HTML标签。 段落1:

    The criminal legal system is composed of many complex decision points, such as which charges are pursued, how bond is determined, plea deal negotiations, and sentencing. Given the profound impact of such decisions, there is a growing need to increase the transparency within this system.

    段落2:

    While prior machine learning approaches have focused on modeling single decisions (e.g., recidivism), this paper proposes a transformer-based time series model to forecast the outcome of the next proceeding in a case (e.g., charges accepted, bond set, plea deal made, etc.). By modeling a case as an event sequence, we enable a more nuanced analysis to support better oversight and understanding of decision making.

    段落3:

    We conduct an empirical analysis of thousands of cases using a newly constructed dataset derived from publicly available court records of a mid-sized U.S. city. We fit models that combine textual data from clerk notes with structured information about the defendant, prior charges, and courtroom. Our transformer model achieves $.57$ micro-F1 on a 20-class multi-label task, a significant improvement over several baselines and comparable to a GRU trained on the same input.

    段落4:

    We demonstrate how the model can be used to provide insights into decision-making and help court observers identify emerging issues within the jurisdiction studied.

    检查是否满足所有规则: 1. 只输出HTML片段本身,不要Markdown围栏、不要解释。 -> 满足 2. 每个自然段落用

    包裹,长文用

    /

    划分小节。 -> 这里不长,直接用

    包裹自然段落即可,不需要强行加h2/h3,因为原文没有小节标题,加的话属于增删内容。 3. 列表内容用

    • ,引用用
      ,代码用
      ,重要句子可用。 -> 使用了。
      4. 保留原文所有信息,不得增删改内容。 -> 满足,文字完全一致。
      5. 不要输出//等文档级标签。 -> 满足。
      
      再核对一下原文和HTML中的文本是否完全一致:
      原文:The criminal legal system is composed of many complex decision points, such as which charges are pursued, how bond is determined, plea deal negotiations, and sentencing. Given the profound impact of such decisions, there is a growing need to increase the transparency within this system.
      HTML: 

      The criminal legal system is composed of many complex decision points, such as which charges are pursued, how bond is determined, plea deal negotiations, and sentencing. Given the profound impact of such decisions, there is a growing need to increase the transparency within this system.

      原文:While prior machine learning approaches have focused on modeling single decisions (e.g., recidivism), this paper proposes a transformer-based time series model to forecast the outcome of the next proceeding in a case (e.g., charges accepted, bond set, plea deal made, etc.). By modeling a case as an event sequence, we enable a more nuanced analysis to support better oversight and understanding of decision making. HTML:

      While prior machine learning approaches have focused on modeling single decisions (e.g., recidivism), this paper proposes a transformer-based time series model to forecast the outcome of the next proceeding in a case (e.g., charges accepted, bond set, plea deal made, etc.). By modeling a case as an event sequence, we enable a more nuanced analysis to support better oversight and understanding of decision making.

      原文:We conduct an empirical analysis of thousands of cases using a newly constructed dataset derived from publicly available court records of a mid-sized U.S. city. We fit models that combine textual data from clerk notes with structured information about the defendant, prior charges, and courtroom. Our transformer model achieves $.57$ micro-F1 on a 20-class multi-label task, a significant improvement over several baselines and comparable to a GRU trained on the same input. HTML:

      We conduct an empirical analysis of thousands of cases using a newly constructed dataset derived from publicly available court records of a mid-sized U.S. city. We fit models that combine textual data from clerk notes with structured information about the defendant, prior charges, and courtroom. Our transformer model achieves $.57$ micro-F1